The short answer is, probably not. But truth be told we all have different skin and even when we share similar issues no product will work the same on 2 individuals. So, do more expensive masks work better than drugstore bought masks? I decided to see for myself by purchasing 3 different masks. The first was Boscia's Luminizing Black Mask (retails for $34 at
http://www.sephora.com/ and
http://www.boscia.net/), the second was Boots Botanics Conditioning Clay Mask (retails for $8.99 at your local Target), and lastly Queen Helene The Original Mint Julep Masque (I got it for $2.75 at my local Dollar Tree but typically retails for $2-$7 online).
Before I start I want to state that personally I have dry sensitive skin that is prone to the occasional breakout. I also have issues with whiteheads and blackheads on my chin/nose areas respectively. Obviously these things affect how I feel about each individual product I mentioned. As you can imagine I always try to purchase products that work with my skin needs and that are either organic or natural (it's more of a preference not a necessity). It is this particular preference that led me to purchase the Boscia mask. After all it has Sephora's organic seal off approval.
Boscia Luminizing Black Mask
The good:
Organic Product
Easy to apply
Dries fairly quickly (15-20 mins. depending on the thickness you apply)
Sinks into every pore on your face
Removes some blackheads and dead skin
The bad:
Difficult to peel off
Stings after removal and skin is sensitive overall
Does not remove most impurities
Does not significantly improve the skins appearance
Amount (2.8 oz)
Price
Where to purchase:
Although Boscia claims its mask "boosts skin clarity and radiance. Removes dirt and impurities while refining the look of pores" it reminds me of a nose strip. Honestly, it's just like one huge Biore strip. And much like a Biore strip it will rip out facial hair, remove some blackheads, and then call it a day. For the price and amount you get I wouldn't say it's worth it. The ironic part is that now Boscia has black nose strips - I guess I wasn't the only one that felt this way about this mask lol.
Boots Botanics Conditioning Mask
The good:
Affordable price
Dries extremely fast
Gets into every single pore on your face
Does not dry your skin
Dried up blemishes
Washed off easily
The bad:
Dries extremely fast
Where to purchase:
Boots Clay Mask works by "exhibiting a negative electrical charge to attract deep-rooted impurities from your skin". What caught my attention was the fact that it claimed to work well for dry skin (as well as normal/combination skin). It isn't often you find a product that really does work for all skin types. That aside, how could I say no when the price was so cheap and I was getting twice as much product than the Boscia mask? The only downside I found was the way the mask dried. At times I wanted to spread the product out but by the time I would get back to an area it would be 50% dry forcing me to have to use more product to compensate. Besides that I really loved this mask. It made my skin feel so clean and soft, especially my nose which is always a troublesome area. I'm not looking for a miracle product but this is pretty darn close. I would definitely recommend this for any skin type.
Queen Helene The Original Mint Julep Masque
The good:
Price
Quantity (8 oz Bonus 33% More)
Consistency
Dries quickly
Sinks into every single pore
Nice tingling sensation
Dried blemishes
Washed off easily
The bad:
The smell (it was like applying toothpaste)
Stung when applied
Left my face very dry
Where to purchase:
This particular mask seems to be quite popular among skin care gurus (just search YouTube and you will see what I mean). Quite frankly I stumbled upon it one day at my local Dollar Tree. I never imagined this would be my third selection, but at $2.75 for an 8 oz tube, how could I say no?
I really enjoyed the thickness of this mask because a little really did go a long way. This tube will probably last me for quite a bit lol. Even though it stung a lot on the initial application, it tingled nicely all the way until it dried. I loved how deep into my pores it went and how quickly it dried up. But, my skin got pretty dry once I removed it - my nose was pretty bad. Fortunately it wasn't anything my night time routine couldn't handle. To my surprise the very next day some blemishes I had dried up but I had broken out in new ones as well - go figure! Ironically I took this as a good sign that it was pulling out deep impurities in my skin. Still, I wouldn't recommend this for people with severely dry/sensitive skin.
Now, down to business. Surely at this point you can guess what my take is on this particular topic. While I absolutely love going to department stores and buying expensive "promises" of amazing results a lot of times you can get the same or even better results from a drugstore brand. Out of the 3 products, Boots won hands down in my opinion. You will just have to see for yourself ^_^.